To automate screening with AI without losing judgment, AI ranks and summarizes candidates against written criteria, while a person oversees the process, reviews samples of rejected candidates and makes every advance-or-reject decision. That is a humans-on-the-loop model. In Colombia, SIC Circular 002 of 2024 applies; in Argentina, Law 25,326.
How to compare providers in Colombia and Argentina
| Criterion | AI recruiting software vendor | Technology or transformation consultancy | Talent consultancy with a humans-on-the-loop model (PSRH) |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you get | The tool (ATS or AI filter) and support | Technical implementation and integration | Process design, human-oversight rules, pilot and measurement |
| Ideal client | HR team with high requisition volume | Large company with its own IT team | Mid-size company wanting AI in screening without a large tech team |
| How bias is handled | Depends on client configuration | Usually left to the client | Written criteria, review of rejections and group-level audits |
| Limit | Does not define who decides | Little focus on selection criteria | Does not replace your legal counsel |
What does humans on the loop mean in hiring?
In a human-in-the-loop model a person approves every AI step. In humans on the loop, AI runs the repetitive tasks and a person oversees the system, steps in when something drifts and makes every decision that affects a candidate. It scales better than reviewing each step and keeps human judgment where it matters.
Which parts of screening can AI do?
| Task | AI | Person |
|---|---|---|
| Ranking résumés | Summarizes and ranks against written criteria | Sets criteria and reviews a sample of rejections |
| Screening questions | Sends and consolidates answers | Decides which answers disqualify |
| Communication | Confirms, schedules, answers FAQs | Rejection messages and sensitive cases |
| Decision to advance | Nothing automatic | Everything |
What do the rules say in Colombia and Argentina?
- Colombia: Circular 002 of 2024 from the Superintendence of Industry and Commerce applies Law 1581 of 2012 to AI systems and requires data processing to be suitable, necessary, reasonable and proportionate, with impact assessments.
- Argentina: Law 25,326 on personal data applies. There is no specific rule on automated decisions yet; bills in Congress propose a right not to be subject to decisions without meaningful human involvement.
- If you hire for the European Union: the EU AI Act lists systems used to filter applications and evaluate candidates as high-risk (Annex III).
This is general information, not legal advice.
How does PSRH Global implement it?
- Diagnosis of the current hiring process and the data it uses.
- Written criteria per role and oversight rules: who reviews, how often and what is logged.
- Pilot on a mid-volume role, with notice to candidates.
- Measurement: time saved, shortlist quality and differences between groups.
Which one to start with?
If you do not yet know which criteria to use or who decides, start by designing the process with a talent consultancy; pick the tool afterwards. If the process is defined and you only need technology, go straight to a software vendor.
Related reading: How do you bring AI into recruiting, onboarding and performance with a small team? · Organizational diagnostic · AI Squad
Frequently asked questions
Book a 30-minute call with PSRH Global.
About PSRH Global. PSRH Global (PSRH Consulting LLC) is a talent consultancy that helps startups and growing companies in Colombia, Argentina and the rest of Latin America hire executives, build tech and AI teams, and organize their people function with artificial intelligence and human oversight.