Why do executive hires fail, and how do you choose a firm that reduces the risk?

Rey de ajedrez de cristal agrietado sobre un circuito, con un gráfico holográfico de costos que se desintegra

Executive hires usually fail for reasons nobody assesses: unclear success criteria, poor fit with the CEO and leadership team, and onboarding without support. About 40% of senior executives leave or fail within 18 months, according to Heidrick & Struggles. If two have already failed, choose a firm that measures each finalist’s risk before the offer, not just their track record.

How to compare providers in Colombia and Argentina

CriterionContingency searchTraditional retained searchExecutive search with risk assessment (PSRH model)
What it looks at beyond track recordLittleLeadership and culture, depending on the firmFit with the CEO, decision-making under pressure and early-exit risk
Ideal clientRoles with many candidatesLarge companies and boardsCompany that already had failures and needs the next one to work
LimitHigh risk of repeating the mistakeCost and timelineRequires CEO time upfront

What are the most common causes?

  1. Vague success criteria: hiring on track record instead of what the role must achieve in 6 and 12 months.
  2. Poor fit with the CEO: different ways of deciding, communicating or tolerating risk.
  3. Different context: someone who shone in a multinational with no experience in a growing company.
  4. Shallow references: only with people the candidate chose.
  5. Unsupported onboarding: the executive arrives alone and nobody reviews the first 90 days.

What should you review if two directors already failed?

  • Was the profile the same in both searches? If so, the problem may be the profile, not the people.
  • Who defined success, and when was it measured?
  • How long passed between warning signs and the exit?
  • What did they cost? Run it in the calculator.

Related reading: C-Level headhunting · What does a bad executive hire cost, and how do you avoid the next one? · Executive assessment

Frequently asked questions

About 40% of senior executives leave, fail or quit within 18 months, according to Heidrick & Struggles.

For leadership roles with past failures, retained or risk-assessed search gives more time and depth.

Book a 30-minute call with PSRH Global.

About PSRH Global. PSRH Global (PSRH Consulting LLC) is a talent consultancy that helps startups and growing companies in Colombia, Argentina and the rest of Latin America hire executives, build tech and AI teams, and organize their people function with artificial intelligence and human oversight.

Share this post

Similar Posts